Legislation Details

File #: 261020    Version: 0 Name:
Type: Bill Status: IN COUNCIL
File created: 11/19/2026 In control: CITY COUNCIL
On agenda: Final action:
Title: Requiring the Department of Human Services to develop and implement a comprehensive plan to transition ongoing child-welfare case management and foster-care placement oversight from privately contracted Community Umbrella Agencies to direct public administration by the Department of Human Services; establishing reporting, accountability, and implementation requirements; and providing for the orderly transition of services to protect the safety, permanency, and well-being of children and families.
Sponsors: Councilmember Bass, Councilmember Phillips, Councilmember Gilmore Richardson, Councilmember Gauthier, Councilmember Thomas, Councilmember Jones, Councilmember Young, Councilmember Brooks, Councilmember Harrity, Councilmember O'Rourke, Councilmember Squilla, Councilmember Ahmad
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultTallyAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

Title

Requiring the Department of Human Services to develop and implement a comprehensive plan to transition ongoing child-welfare case management and foster-care placement oversight from privately contracted Community Umbrella Agencies to direct public administration by the Department of Human Services; establishing reporting, accountability, and implementation requirements; and providing for the orderly transition of services to protect the safety, permanency, and well-being of children and families.

 

Body

WHEREAS, The City of Philadelphia, through its Department of Human Services (DHS), is responsible for administering the City's child-welfare system and fulfilling its obligations as the county children and youth agency under applicable Pennsylvania law; and

 

WHEREAS, Following the 2006 death of Danieal Kelly, a fourteen-year-old Philadelphia child with cerebral palsy, the City undertook a review of its child-welfare system and subsequently developed the Improving Outcomes for Children initiative, which established the Community Umbrella Agency (CUA) model; and

 

WHEREAS, The CUA model transferred responsibility for ongoing child-welfare case management, including family service planning and coordination and oversight of foster-care placements, to privately contracted nonprofit organizations operating within designated geographic regions of Philadelphia; and

 

WHEREAS, Although the CUA model was established with the stated objectives of improving child safety, strengthening accountability, promoting family preservation, and providing community-based services, the City retains ultimate responsibility for the safety and well-being of children involved in the child-welfare system; and

 

WHEREAS, Questions have been raised concerning the effectiveness, oversight, accountability, staffing, performance measurement, and financial management of the CUA system, including whether the current public-private structure adequately protects children and supports families; and

 

WHEREAS, The continued occurrence of child fatalities and near-fatalities involving children known to the child-welfare system underscores the importance of examining the City's current service-delivery structure and the adequacy of its oversight and accountability mechanisms; and

 

WHEREAS, Direct public administration of ongoing child-welfare case management would place responsibility for these essential governmental functions within the Department of Human Services and under the direct supervision and accountability of public employees; and

 

WHEREAS, Pennsylvania law establishes responsibilities for county children and youth agencies, including requirements concerning staffing, case management, family service planning, placement oversight, and the provision and monitoring of protective services; and

 

WHEREAS, The City seeks to examine and implement a service-delivery structure that fulfills all applicable state and federal requirements while strengthening public accountability and ensuring continuity of care for children and families; now, therefore,

 

THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA HEREBY ORDAINS:

 

SECTION 1. Purpose and Legislative Intent.

 

The purpose of this Ordinance is to establish a framework for transitioning the administration of ongoing child-welfare case management and foster-care placement oversight from privately contracted Community Umbrella Agencies to direct public administration by the Department of Human Services.

 

The Council intends that:

(a) DHS assume direct administrative responsibility for ongoing child-welfare case management through qualified public employees.

(b) Children and families receive consistent, coordinated, and uninterrupted services throughout the transition.

(c) The City strengthen public accountability, transparency, and oversight of child-welfare decisions and services.

(d) The transition preserve the ability of DHS to contract with qualified nonprofit and community-based organizations for direct services, including behavioral health, prevention, family support, foster-care placement services, and other specialized services, as permitted by law.

(e) The City maintain full compliance with applicable federal and Pennsylvania child-welfare laws, regulations, funding requirements, and court obligations.

 

SECTION 2. Definitions.

For purposes of this Ordinance:

(a) Community Umbrella Agency (CUA) means a private nonprofit or other organization contracted by DHS to provide ongoing child-welfare case management within one or more designated geographic regions of Philadelphia under the Improving Outcomes for Children initiative.

(b) Ongoing Child-Welfare Case Management means the continuing management and oversight of cases involving children and families accepted for services by DHS, including family service planning, case reviews, coordination of services, monitoring of child safety and well-being, and coordination of permanency efforts.

(c) Foster-Care Placement Oversight means responsibility for monitoring the safety, appropriateness, stability, and progress of children placed outside their homes, including coordination of placement reviews, family reunification efforts, and permanency planning.

(d) Direct Public Administration means the performance of ongoing child-welfare case-management and associated oversight responsibilities by employees of the City of Philadelphia under the supervision and authority of DHS, rather than through the delegation of primary case-management responsibility to privately contracted CUA operators.

(e) Transition Plan means the comprehensive implementation plan required under Section 3 of this Ordinance.

SECTION 3. Development of a Comprehensive Transition Plan.

Within one hundred eighty (180) days of the effective date of this Ordinance, DHS shall develop and submit to the Mayor and City Council a comprehensive plan for transitioning ongoing child-welfare case management and foster-care placement oversight from the existing CUA structure to direct public administration.

 

The Transition Plan shall include, at a minimum:

(a) Organizational Structure and Administration.

1.                     A proposed organizational structure for the administration of ongoing child-welfare case management within DHS.

2.                     Identification of the functions and responsibilities currently performed by CUA contractors that will be assumed by DHS employees.

3.                     Identification of supervisory, managerial, administrative, and operational positions necessary to support direct public administration.

4.                     A proposed implementation schedule identifying major milestones and responsible administrative units.

(b) Staffing and Workforce Development.

1.                     An assessment of the number and qualifications of employees necessary to assume ongoing case-management responsibilities.

2.                     A staffing plan addressing caseloads, supervisory ratios, workload distribution, and geographic assignments.

3.                     A recruitment and retention strategy for qualified child-welfare professionals.

4.                     A training and professional development program addressing child safety, trauma-informed care, family engagement, disability accommodations, cultural competency, and applicable legal requirements.

5.                     An assessment of opportunities for qualified CUA employees to apply for positions within DHS, subject to applicable civil service requirements, collective bargaining agreements, and other employment laws.

(c) Transfer of Case Management Responsibilities.

1.                     A detailed process for transferring active child-welfare cases from CUA contractors to DHS employees.

2.                     Procedures to ensure the accurate and secure transfer of case records, assessments, service plans, placement histories, and other relevant documentation.

3.                     Identification of safeguards to prevent interruptions in case management, family engagement, court appearances, and required child welfare services.

4.                     Procedures for assigning a designated DHS case manager to each child and family receiving ongoing services.

5.                     A process for identifying and prioritizing cases involving children at heightened risk of abuse, neglect, exploitation, or placement instability.

(d) Foster-Care and Permanency Oversight.

1.                     A plan for transferring oversight of foster-care placements and placement-related case management to DHS employees.

2.                     Procedures for monitoring foster homes and congregate-care placements.

3.                     A plan for maintaining continuity in family reunification, adoption, and permanency planning.

4.                     Procedures for ensuring that children with disabilities and other specialized needs receive appropriate placement, medical care, educational support, and services.

5.                     A process for ensuring compliance with applicable court orders, case review requirements, and federal and state permanency timelines.

 

(e) Financial and Budgetary Impact.

1.                     An assessment of the current annual expenditures associated with CUA operating contracts.

2.                     A projected budget for implementing direct public administration.

3.                     Identification of anticipated personnel, technology, facilities, training, and administrative costs.

4.                     An assessment of potential cost savings or additional expenditures resulting from the transition.

5.                     Identification of federal, state, and local funding sources that may support the proposed structure.

6.                     An analysis of any potential impact on federal and state reimbursement eligibility.

 

(f) Technology and Records Management.

1.                     An assessment of existing case-management technology and information systems.

2.                     A plan to ensure that DHS employees have access to complete and accurate case records.

3.                     Procedures for maintaining data security, confidentiality, and compliance with applicable child-welfare information-sharing requirements.

4.                     Identification of necessary technology improvements to support direct public administration.

 

(g) Contractual and Legal Considerations.

1.                     An inventory of existing CUA contracts, including expiration dates, renewal provisions, amendments, and termination requirements.

2.                     An assessment of the legal and financial obligations associated with transitioning away from existing CUA contracts.

3.                     Identification of applicable federal and state laws, regulations, and funding requirements.

4.                     An assessment of any required approvals, waivers, or coordination with the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services.

5.                     Recommendations for the orderly expiration, modification, or termination of CUA operating contracts consistent with applicable law and contractual obligations.

 

(h) Community and Family Engagement.

1.                     A process for soliciting input from parents, foster parents, youth, community organizations, service providers, and child-welfare advocates.

2.                     A plan for communicating changes in case-management assignments and service delivery to affected children and families.

3.                     A process for receiving and responding to complaints and concerns during the transition.

4.                     Recommendations for maintaining meaningful community participation and neighborhood-based service coordination.

 

SECTION 4. Implementation of Direct Public Administration.

(a) Following submission of the Transition Plan, DHS shall proceed with implementation in accordance with the schedule established in the Plan, subject to applicable law, contractual obligations, and required appropriations.

(b) DHS shall establish a target date for completing the transition to direct public administration that shall not exceed twenty-four (24) months following submission of the Transition Plan, unless an extension is authorized by applicable law.

(c) DHS shall progressively assume responsibility for ongoing child-welfare case management, including family service planning, case reviews, coordination of services, monitoring of child safety, and permanency planning.

(d) DHS shall assume direct public administrative responsibility for foster-care placement oversight and related case-management functions.

(e) The transition shall not diminish DHS's existing legal responsibilities as the county children and youth agency.

(f) DHS may continue to contract with qualified nonprofit organizations and other providers for direct services, specialized treatment, prevention services, foster-care services, family support, and other services as permitted by applicable law. Such contracts shall not delegate primary responsibility for ongoing case management to a CUA operating entity.

 

SECTION 5. Protection of Children and Families During the Transition.

(a) DHS shall ensure that no child or family experiences an interruption in required protective services, case management, foster-care oversight, or other legally mandated services as a result of the transition.

(b) DHS shall establish procedures to ensure that every child and family receiving ongoing services has an identified case manager and a designated supervisory contact throughout the transition.

(c) DHS shall prioritize the transfer and review of cases involving:

1.                     Children identified as being at high risk of abuse or neglect.

2.                     Children in foster care or other out-of-home placements.

3.                     Children with disabilities or significant medical, behavioral, or developmental needs.

4.                     Children with histories of repeated placements or placement instability.

5.                     Children approaching permanency deadlines or requiring immediate court intervention.

(d) DHS shall establish a process for identifying and correcting any gaps in case documentation, service delivery, or placement oversight identified during the transition.

(e) Nothing in this Ordinance shall authorize a reduction in legally required services or protections for children and families.

 

SECTION 6. Public Reporting and Accountability.

(a) DHS shall submit quarterly written progress reports to the appropriate City Council committee during the implementation period.

(b) Each report shall include:

1.                     Progress toward implementation milestones.

2.                     The number of DHS employees recruited, hired, trained, and assigned to case-management responsibilities.

3.                     Staffing levels, caseloads, and supervisory ratios.

4.                     The number of child-welfare cases transferred to direct DHS management.

5.                     The status of foster-care placement oversight responsibilities.

6.                     The status of existing CUA contracts and associated expenditures.

7.                     Any identified service interruptions, implementation challenges, or corrective actions.

8.                     Any anticipated changes in expenditures or funding requirements.

9.                     Measures taken to protect children and families during the transition.

(c) DHS shall provide a final implementation report to City Council within ninety (90) days following completion of the transition.

(d) Reports shall be made publicly available, except for information protected by applicable confidentiality laws and regulations.

 

SECTION 7. Severability.

If any provision of this Ordinance or the application thereof to any person or circumstance is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the remaining provisions or applications of this Ordinance that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.

 

SECTION 9. Effective Date.

This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon becoming law.

End